I feel compelled to continue the Streisand effect that the Life Legal Defense Foundation’s opposition to one Tyson Anderson’s poem has caused.
Apparently, California Institute for Regenerative Medicine sponsored a contest soliciting poems about stem cell research. They did this last year (you can find the winners here) and again this year, in honor of Stem Cell Awareness Day on October 6. The winner this year will get a [pretty awesome, akshly] framed electron microscope stem cell image (of their choice). Entries were duly submitted, judged, and announced. The winning poems were, of course, posted on CIRM’s site.
Two days later, all of this year’s poems were taken down. Stem C., by Tyson Anderson, was objected to by LLDF as “blasphemous”, “propaganda”, and “pilfering of the holiest of voluntary, sacrificial acts in the history of humanity” (by which they mean mythology, unless they’ve unearthed evidence I’ve not heard of). They additionally argued that it contained an “inadvertent acknowledgment of the personhood of […] embryos”. I think they’re giving far too little credit to the poet: words in poems are rarely “inadvertent” and very often ascribe personhood to animals, concepts, and inanimate objects. It’s called personification and the LLDF has clearly never heard of it.
Stem C. came in first place, but the second place poem, Birth, Rebirth by Andy Levy (which is beautiful, by the way) did not escape LLDF’s righteous furor. They, and their band of parroting ideologues, in two days convinced CIRM to take down the poems. At the moment, they can still be read here (and at other sites dedicated to defeating this censorship).
Having no permission to do so, but hoping that the authors understand my intent to battle religious extremism against them, the four published-then-unpublished poems are below the fold.
The winner:
Stem C.
, by Tyson Anderson
This is my body
which is given for you.
But I am not great.
I have neither wealth,
nor fame, nor grace.
I cannot comfort with words,
nor inspire to march.
I am small and simple,
so leave me this.
Let me heal you.
This is my body
which is given for you.
Take this
in remembrance of me.
The runner-up:
Birth, Rebirth
, by Andy Levy
One cell, followed by many more
The mosaic forms a new life
A young child will freely soar
Yet untouched by sadness or strife.
The cells divide, and we behold
Newborn, toddler and then a teen
Innocence turns to loud and bold
A movie, never before seen.
With all the world in front of her
She runs, she flies, and shows her flair
But all these things become a blur
When she learns life is so unfair.
Trouble now looms down deep inside
When all those cells begin to fail
There is no place to run and hide
When the body becomes a jail.
She deserves a much better fate
Science and chemistry are key
Make healthy cells regenerate
And give her back her destiny.
Despair gives way to passion
And she demonstrates strength and grace
We are driven to take action
At a steady frenetic pace.
Together we can change the course
With lots of hard work to be sure
New stem cells will provide the source
Of discoveries yielding a cure.
Two honorable mentions:
Replanting Neurons
, by Celia Berrell
The beauty of movement.
Some tendrils of hope
are glimpsed in a garden
through one microscope.
The flowers of life
and the fruit of our soul
require every stem to be
sturdy and whole.
We graft weed and nurture
our gardens with pride.
What grows and what goes
is for us to decide.
Where pathways are broken
a wheelchair can’t reach.
But stem cell researchers
are mending that breach.
and
the Stem Cell and the Scientist, by Kandy L. Bain
Small but mighty
Here I am undifferentiated
With no destination just yet……….
Until
I am poked ever so carefully with a small
Metal tube containing some
Information full of direction
Then
Here I am filled with new direction
All
Because the Scientist and I
Worked together………
Together we can give rise to
Anything.
Personally, I think science-themed art is très awesome and that we should encourage it, not censor it. But, of course, I’m not a religious nut (any more), so that might explain why I don’t see the clear destruction of humanity as we know it that poetry represents.
via the Freethinker
I will, of course, remove the poems should the authors (or CIRM) desire narrower dissemination. Please simply email me.