The BBC put out a much more reasoned report about the statue. Basically saying the same thing this author does: we’re imposing entirely too many modern concepts on a 35,000 year old figure. And of course now I can’t find the link. I’ll try again this afternoon, maybe.
At any rate, thanks for *this* link. What a scathing critique of the biases that go into modern science.
I’ve been doing a lot of scholarly/archaeological research into idols / figurines and their manufacture in the fertile crescent region. This looks like a common household figurine found in Mesopotamia & Israel – a fertility goddess of some type. It’s definitely not pornographic.
One thing I have noticed in this field is that scholars and researchers say outlandish things to get published, not to be truthful. They have a lot of pressure to publish, so they put out any crap and come to ridiculous conclusions. The old saying for those in the field of archaeology and near-eastern studies is “publish or perish.” Sadly, too many choose the former.
John & xJane
Mind on Fire is devoted to spirituality and skepticism, with frequent detours into science fiction, feminism, and other (mostly geeky) pet topics. It aims to be respectfully iconoclastic and thoroughly sacrilicious.
4 responses so far ↓
1 Lessie // May 17, 2009 at 7:42 am
The BBC put out a much more reasoned report about the statue. Basically saying the same thing this author does: we’re imposing entirely too many modern concepts on a 35,000 year old figure. And of course now I can’t find the link. I’ll try again this afternoon, maybe.
At any rate, thanks for *this* link. What a scathing critique of the biases that go into modern science.
2 Jonathan // May 29, 2009 at 6:00 am
I’ve been doing a lot of scholarly/archaeological research into idols / figurines and their manufacture in the fertile crescent region. This looks like a common household figurine found in Mesopotamia & Israel – a fertility goddess of some type. It’s definitely not pornographic.
One thing I have noticed in this field is that scholars and researchers say outlandish things to get published, not to be truthful. They have a lot of pressure to publish, so they put out any crap and come to ridiculous conclusions. The old saying for those in the field of archaeology and near-eastern studies is “publish or perish.” Sadly, too many choose the former.
3 aaaaaddddddddd // Oct 14, 2009 at 5:00 am
i think it is the oldest
4 aaaaaddddddddd // Oct 14, 2009 at 5:01 am
and im just a kid
Leave a Comment