Religion, SF, and Other Speculative Fictions.


Mind on Fire random header image

Batman is a Lapsed Catholic

Posted by John on January 14th, 2008 at 10:45 pm · 2 Comments

Can you name Superman’s religious affiliation?  How about Hellboy’s?  Is anyone surprised to learn that Lex Luthor is portrayed, at least in one of his many incarnations, as a “Nietzschean atheist?” Adherents.com has an alternately comprehensive/tenuous listing of super heroes, sidekicks and villains and their religions.  If, like me, you’re into comics and religion (get a life!), this is a wellspring of conversation (and possible heated debates).

While religion didn’t dominate the comics of the 80s that I grew up on, the writers of my favorite monthlies made religion an important part of the back story.  My high school crush, Kitty Pride (aka Shadowcat of the X-men), was Jewish, Nightcrawler was a devout German Catholic, and Wolverine (characteristically) refused to be nailed down–at times he was a Western atheist, at others he flirted with Japanese Buddhism and Shintoism.  The comics I read now confront Christian cultural tradition head on, drawing on the rich heritage to spin new stories.  John Constantine, the magic-wielding humanist, struggles against the powers of heaven and hell; Spawn, an atheist resurrected by a demon of hell to become a lieutenant in Hell’s army (who subsequently rebels against this role); Hellboy, the demon child rescued from hell and who is raised to become a devout Catholic.  Neil Gaiman’s worlds are populated with Biblical and apocryphal characters.

Comics are an incredible venue for exploring religion.  Arguably, our age’s greatest mythical heroes were born in these cheap, colorful pages.  Artists and writers regularly co-opt religious symbolism and stories and refashion them to serve their own storytelling purposes (thus continuing what storytellers have been doing for millennia).  Finally, for all of their incredible powers or strange circumstances, the best written characters struggle with the humanizing issues of tradition and individualism, of faith and doubt.

Tags: Comics · Religion · SF

2 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Kevin // Jan 15, 2008 at 11:07 am

    O poor Nietzsche – his overtly large mustache keeps him from being associated with anyone but megalomaniacs and serial killers. I have a book (in a different country) that lists all the different times Nietzsche is referenced in pop culture. The person reading a Nietzsche book in a movie is usually a killer or otherwise mentally disturbed.
    The “only” connection between Nietzsche and Lex is the first and terrible translation of Nietzsche’s use of the word “Übermensch”. The translator turned this into “Superman” whereas the literal translation is “Overhuman” and the (now) recognized translation is “Overman”. The translation, “Superman”, gave English readers strange ideas as to what Nietzsche could have meant. Does he wear a cape? does he fly? super strength? But of course!
    Sorry for ranting.

  • 2 xJane // Jan 18, 2008 at 8:18 am

    I never thought about it too much with my heroes. It seems like they’re strong enough (even with their weaknesses) not to need religion. Which makes Nightcrawler that much more of an anomaly: no one else was, to me, obviously faithful. In terms of my favorites: Storm was a goddess, what need had she of religion?; same for Wonder Woman, although if I had to guess, I’d say Olympian-Greek; Constantine was awesome because he knew there was a god and a hell but was still an atheist (okay, humanist, I got that one wrong).

    And dittos to Kevin re: Nietzsche.

Leave a Comment