Religion, SF, and Other Speculative Fictions.


Mind on Fire random header image

Exploration of a Theme: the Perceived Threat of Homosexual Relationships

Posted by xJane on August 28th, 2007 at 6:52 am · 4 Comments

I was reading an article in Mother Jones (it’s not online yet, I’ll link to it when it is) about homosexuality and “cures”. I’d like to steer clear of whether or not it can be cured, is psycholgical vs. physical, or any of that stuff. What I’d like to explore is the reason that (often right-leaning) people want to believe that it is “curable”. What came to my mind as I was reading this was the possibility that a reason this is such important point to people is equality.

Bear with me for a moment. If homosexual relationships are “okay”, “acceptable”, or “natural”, however you want to frame it, then heterosexual relationships might turn into relationships of equals. So much of the debate in question is answered with “breakdown of traditional marriage!” which could be phrased as a marriage of non-equals. Perhaps a reason why people find male-male and female-female relationships so threatening is because it might mean that a female-male relationship could also be a relationship of equals.

This was a thought driven home rather forcefully the other day when a creepy (read: trapped-in-the-dark-ages) guy tried to pick me up by declaring that he would love to have a woman cook for him! When I responded that I like having a man cook for me, he became confused by that concept. What he needed to understand was that I was not interested in a “traditional marriage” but in a marriage of equals.

Obviously there are many factors at issue with arguments both for and against homosexual relationships. But the issue of equality seems to be one that underlies many of the arguments used. Thoughts?

Tags: Gender · Sexuality

4 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Craig // Feb 11, 2009 at 6:57 pm

    I can’t believe no one ever commented on this before.

    I think you are (were) absolutely right. Especially in religious cultures like Mormonism where the woman is traditionally NOT equal at all, there is the threat (just as with the ERA) that people will start to get *ideas* about being equal and deserving equal treatment all the time

    Scary if you’re the leader of a patriarchal church that has institutionalised sexism and homophobia.

  • 2 xJane // Feb 12, 2009 at 11:30 am

    or a woman who has managed to scrabble some vague form of leadership within the confines of that patriarchal church—for her, women demanding equality is even more dangerous, since she stands to lose all she has worked for. This is why I think “women’s rights” are so intertwined with other “minority” rights—race, orientation, gender identification, parental…

  • 3 Craig // Feb 12, 2009 at 3:42 pm

    Yeah, I see that all the time in Mormonism – women who have some semblance of authority are often the most misogynistic.

  • 4 Craig // Feb 12, 2009 at 3:44 pm

    In fact, I can think of lots and lots of conference talks that prove that point (and one very disturbing one in particular)

Leave a Comment